After the floods, Bengaluru needs to clean up its act
The floods have abated in Bengaluru. As individuals struggle to clean their houses, the silt on the roads left behind by the receding water — now a fine dust that flies in the air choking us — is a reminder of those difficult times.Bengaluru needs to clean
Various analyses
now attribute Bengaluru’s flooding to more rainfall — in the future, it is
expected to increase to an average of 1,000 mm per annum from the current 650
mm per annum— and unplanned, overcrowded growth that is destroying the
greenery, tanks and wetlands.
Clearly, we must
decongest the city, plant more trees, save wetlands, even reclaim them, desilt
drains, enlarge sewers, deconcretise pavements and stop the clogging of
waterways with unsegregated garbage. The State government announced tough
measures such as the demolition of unauthorised encroachments impeding drainage
streams in the city, but quickly backed away. It now plans to divert drains to
avoid already builtup areas. This is not a solution because nature will carry
on inundating encroachments until people abandon them of their own volition.Bengaluru needs to clean
The ‘grease’ of the system
Everybody has a
favourite villain to blame — from the builder mafia to the migrant, from the
lack of spatial planning to uncontrolled violations of building byelaws. Yet, the herd of restive elephants in the room is led by
a particularly malevolent matriarch: corruption.
Everybody decries corruption outwardly,
but submits to it meekly. Fear apart, it is also
a matter of convenience, of time saved and of benefits, often through the
violation of rules. Some justify corruption as the grease that keeps the
fastgrowing
economic engine of Bengaluru whirring smoothly. However, corruption cripples
economic growth in ways not readily apparent. Apart from transferring
inordinate wealth to the undeserving, it creates a slew of vested interests,
who resist anticorruption process reforms. Understanding how corrupt officials,
politicians, egulators and private players act in concert is essential to
successfully implementing corruptionreducing strategies. Further, we must
understand that the corrupt often use the honest to further their subversive
agendas. Examples abound.Bengaluru needs to clean
Most game
theories concerning the dynamics of corruption reveal that the original sinner
is often, paradoxically, a wellintentioned government. A good, but misguided
government could make narrowly rigid rules, thus giving venal politicians and
bureaucrats the leeway to bend them. For example, building byelaws are so
labyrinthine that the strictest lawabiding citizen cannot comply with them.
That provides opportunities for agents who bypass the system’s rigidities.
Ironically then, corruption actually reduces red tape. Hence, not many complain
about resorting to bribing to get work done through a parallel, ‘efficient’ system.Bengaluru needs to clean
One could also
have a good government that aims to reduce red tape, making overly lax rules
capable of being interpreted differently. In this
‘anything goes’,
system, frontline officials invent discretionary practices to create impediments
and seek bribes. ‘You show me your face, and I’ll show you the rule,’ is an old and cynical adage.
The loopholes
Next, our
narrow, legal definition of corruption enables many in a corrupt system to
escape culpability. Indian law recognises only corrupt acts by public servantsto be ‘acts of corruption’
under the law. As private corruption is not criminalised, many government
actions are outsourced to private agents, who collect.Bengaluru needs to clean
‘handling fees’
on behalf of their partners in crime within the government. Witness builders’
agents, who collect bribes openly to have properties registered, even as the
government IT enable such processes, aiming at efficiency and honesty.
EGovernance is
often not the effective solution as claimed. Eenabled
systems often only relocate the locus of corruption; they do not solve all of
it. Large databases, such as land records, when moved to paperless systems are
vulnerable to manipulation. Encroachments are enabled when old records are
destroyed and new ones are created. Power shifts from land administrators to
the one who possesses the digital signature. The data entry operator becomes an
allimportant and corruptible cog in the wheel.
How then do we
tackle corruption? How do we destroy the entrenched resistance to true reforms,
which harmonises citizen and collective interest in protecting the environment
and promoting a healthy economy? Worldwide experience reveals no easy way out.
The battle against networks of corrupt interests of politicians, bureaucrats,
the private sector and regulators, has been a hard fought one. There are uneasy
transitions and fake equilibriums in this battle of attrition; the corrupt do
not cede ground easily.Bengaluru needs to clean
Kick-start these strategies
Successful
anticorruption strategies rely on actions across three fronts.
First, regular
assessments and evaluations of ongoing anticorruption measures, eliminate the
possibility of declaring false victories. They help in redflagging new
corruption opportunities, even as old ones are eliminated. A cycle of ongoing
process reforms gets initiated.
Second, a
genuine regime of whistleblower protection assures honest citizens,
politicians, bureaucrats and judges of protection, as they otherwise fear theadverse repercussions for uncovering illegal activities. Whistleblowers today
are exposed to danger. They draw attention to themselves and are vulnerable to
attacks, ranging from character assassination, to counter accusations, to
physical harm. Confidenceassuring whistleblower protection measures can lead to exposure of more
corruption, particularly at higher levels. Swift punishment of the guilty,
could instil a sense of fear and reduce the feeling of impunity that the
corrupt enjoy.
Third, there has
to be a conscious move towards promoting ethical behaviour. Unfortunately,
moral science education has been tainted by religious colours; but surely, are
we not able to develop agnostic, religionneutral ways of educating young
people to be empathetic, kind, mindful of their larger responsibilities to the
community, be honest, and intolerant of corruption?
All these
strategies have been tried successfully in countries and cultures that have
been able to reduce corruption substantially. This in turn has translated into
better quality of services, and thus, a better quality of life. In turn, this
nurtures creativity and bolsters the economy. Surely, Bengaluru deserves such a
future.Bengaluru needs to clean
However,
there
is one necessary ingredient remaining, going by the experience of cities and
countries that have cleaned up their acts. If
anticorruption
strategies are to be successful, Bengaluru needs to clean the process needs enlightened leadership. No
extent of process changes will succeed if the leadership— it need not be a
single leader, but a network of highranking individuals cutting across the
government and nongovernment sectors — is corrupt or insincere. In ademocracy, waiting for such a leadership to emerge miraculously from socalled
benevolent dictators is wishful thinking. The emergence of such a leadership
depends upon us.
IF YOU WANT TO MORE INFORMATION REGARDING TO SEO RANK PAGE CLICK
0 Comments